Episode 1.19 How Can You Be Sure? (spoilers)

[Still Dirrty]

Lucas (Chad Michael Murray) must make a difficult decision regarding Brooke (Sophia Bush). Haley (Bethany Joy Lenz) considers having sex with Nathan (James Lafferty).

Be warned: SPOILERS INCLUDED!

I posted this on an OTH message board, thought I'd share it with all of you:

Okay...

I think if Brooke's really pregnent, it's either Lucas' baby, or someone else, but I highly doubt it's the man at the bar. I think the writer did that to trick us into thinking it's his baby, but really, it isn't. But I am almost positive we'll be seeing more of that guy, because I don't think he would have just, shown up in the episode for no reason.

I DON'T think it will be a miscarrige (SP?). Think about it... they are almost re-creating the whole Dan/Karen/Deb story.

In the preview, we see Dan telling Lucas Brooke should abort the baby. As for how Dan find out and gives him the advice, it almost looks like it's in a doctors office. I could be wrong, but who knows.

Also, we've heard from Spoilers that Dan becomes the basketball coach at sometime, so maybe that's when.

I could be wrong on all of these, but these are just my guesses.

I truly belive that Brooke lied about her being
pregnent and in further more she needs to stop
this bussiness of being rude and ugly towards
Lucas.

As for Dan he needs his butt kicked for asking
Karen to abort Lucas before he was born, because
like Karen said she loved Lucas very dearly and
she wanted to give birth to him and I'm very
proud of her for doing that.

Lucas is human just like everybody else and he
had every right to be born and it would not have
been the same if Karen had not given birth to
Lucas. [img]graemlins/thumbs.gif[/img] ;)

:mad: Oh my gosh!

I am soooooo mad at Brooke! How could she lie to Lucas like that???? I mean, it was one thing to tell him she thinks she's pregnant when she truly didn't know, but it's totally another when she finds out that she's not but keeps on telling Lucas that she was!!!
I know that Brooke is still really mad at Lucas for cheating on her with Peyton, but I don't think it's fair to Lucas to make him worry so much. He was telling her that he would stick by her and he wouldn't leave her and that he would be a good father, and then Brooke had to go and tell him that she lied!!! I don't think Lucas is ever going to trust Brooke again. [img]graemlins/yuk.gif[/img]
As for Keith and Karen, I feel really bad for the guy. He put his heart on the line and he got rejected. But I do understand that Karen doesn't feel for him that way. Now Keith is thinking about moving.
Also, I don't understand the whole Peyton/Nicki thing. Peyton is just Jenny's babysitter, and if Nicki thinks that Peyton is trying to become Jenny's mother then she is totally wrong. I don't think she'd be a good mother for Jenny anyway.
I CAN'T BELIEVE Dan! :mad:
I can't believe he told Lucas that he told Karen to get an abortion. He was like, "If your mother was smart, she would have gotten an abortion like I told her too." That is so mean! It is absolutely none of his business about Brooke. He shouldn't give Lucas advice.
Sorry this was so long! [img]graemlins/goofy.gif[/img]

I can't WAIT until next Tuesday's episode!

[shorty213]

HEY EVERYONE

YEAH I THINK IT WAS TOTAL WRONG FOR BROOKE TO LIE TO HIM. I KNOW SHE IS MAD AT HIM BUT STILL THAT IS VERY WRONG OF HER TO DO THAT. [img]graemlins/shake.gif[/img] SHE SHOULD TOLD HIM THE TRUTH RIGHT AWAY.

YEAH I THINK WHAT DAN DID WAS WRONG FOR TELLING LUCAS THAT HE DIDN'T WANT HIM TO BE BORN. [img]graemlins/flame.gif[/img]

Brooke has NO right to lie to Lucas! I mean, what he and Payton did was in the past. Brooke should just let it fly and get on with life! Don't get back at someone by lying! [img]graemlins/steaming.gif[/img] [img]graemlins/flame.gif[/img] GRRRRRR!!!!

i think brroke is really pregnant and just telling lucas that she isnt so he dont worry about her an dtry to come around her. but it wuz strait up bogus for brooke to do that to him. but seriously u can just tell that she really was prego.just my opinion but thats wut i think.