Does Hilary sing live or does she lip sync?

I just watched On Air w/ Ryan and her performance seemed a bit fishy. Her voice didn't shake at all when she was jumping around. I dunno about you but I think it's pretty lame to do that. =/

she dont' sing live, but her band plays live.

It's understandable...if you hear some of the tape in the recording studio she doesn't stay in tune enough. It's fine though, a lot of pop singers dont' sing live in many occasions.

[i_survived_disturbia]

I think in some concerts she sings live, but most of them she doesn't. Which is understandable because she moves around a lot. I think though for her Birthday Bash she sang live because that was why she was so nervous. For her music videos, she doesn't.

[Still Dirrty]

she lipsyncs

You sounded very sure of yourself with that short sentance Dirrty.

She sings live in concert but lipsyncs on tv shows. That is VERY common. I saw her in concert and her performance was incredible. She also performed live at the AMAs and didn't lipsync.

[Still Dirrty]

nah, she lipsynced at the AMA's and she also lipsynces at some performances. Just read all the concert reviews.

Who cares if she lipsings or not! Its still her voice live or not. And I have to agree I think she sings live for concerts but lips for the tv shows which is very very commmon.

I don't know Dirrty, the only reviews I read were before I saw her myself. One spoke of her voice being shaky at times and the other said her tiny voice was overpowered by her band. I've seen her in concert twice and she wasn't lipsyncing either time, it was very obvious. So, if she does lipsync at some performances I'm glad she didn't when I saw her.